Vol. 5 • Deck 18 • American Civics

American Politics:
Then & Now

A democracy that started with 6% of the public able to vote. A government that now listens to roughly the same percentage.

17%
Americans who trust the federal government today — down from 77% in 1964 — Pew Research 2025

Was American Democracy
Ever Built for Everyone?

The U.S. Constitution was written by 55 delegates — all white, all male, all wealthy, most enslaved people. The document they produced protected property far more than people. Understanding where we are now requires being clear about where we started.

6%
Could Vote at Founding
White, male, property-owning, 21+ only
68:1
Senate Representation Gap
Wyoming vs. California vote weight today
70%
of Americans by 2040
Will be represented by just 30% of U.S. senators
1996
Last Year GOP Won Senate Popular Vote
Yet controlled the Senate in 7 of the last 12 terms
Expansion of U.S. Voting Rights Over Time (% of Total Population Eligible to Vote)
Source: U.S. Census Bureau historical data; Congressional Research Service; Brennan Center for Justice. Percentages reflect approximate share of total U.S. population eligible to vote at each milestone date.

Who Got the Vote,
When — and at What Cost

Every expansion of democracy in American history was fought for — by people who were beaten, imprisoned, and killed for it. None of it was given voluntarily by those in power. And with each expansion, new methods of suppression followed almost immediately.

1789
Constitution Ratified — ~6% Eligible
White, male, property-owning men over 21. Women, enslaved people, Indigenous people, poor whites, and religious minorities all excluded.
1870
15th Amendment — Black Men Legally Enfranchised
The amendment passed. Then came poll taxes, literacy tests, grandfather clauses, white primaries, and violence. Reconstruction was already ending.
1920
19th Amendment — Women Win the Vote
After 72 years of organizing. The amendment text mirrored the 15th Amendment. Black women in the South were immediately blocked by the same suppression tactics.
1965
Voting Rights Act — Federal Enforcement
Passed after Bloody Sunday in Selma. The federal government finally began enforcing rights that had been on paper for 95 years.
2013
Shelby County v. Holder — VRA Gutted
Supreme Court removed preclearance requirements. Within 24 hours, states previously covered began closing polling locations and passing voter ID laws.
2024
Record Voter Suppression Legislation
28 states passed 80+ restrictive voting laws since 2020. The Brennan Center documented the most concentrated period of voting restrictions in post-VRA history.

How Money Ate
American Democracy

Citizens United v. FEC (2010) declared that corporations have First Amendment rights and money is speech. The decision removed nearly all limits on outside political spending. What followed was not a vibrant democracy — it was an auction.

Outside Spending in Federal Elections — 2004 to 2024 (USD Billions)
Source: OpenSecrets; Brennan Center for Justice. Dark money includes spending from 501(c)(4) nonprofits not required to disclose donors. Citizens United decided January 2010.
$4.4B
Federal Lobbying in 2024
All-time record — OpenSecrets 2025
$1.9B
Dark Money in 2024
Up from under $5M in 2006 — Brennan Center
$16B
Total 2024 Election Spending
Most expensive election in world history — OpenSecrets
10%
Political Donors Are People of Color
Despite being 40%+ of the population — Demos "Stacked Deck"

Princeton political scientists Gilens and Page analyzed 1,779 policy outcomes and found that average citizens have “little or no independent influence” on U.S. policy. Economic elites and organized interest groups have “substantial independent impact.” The policies most Americans want — 70%, 80%, 85% approval — do not become law.

Gilens & Page, “Testing Theories of American Politics,” Perspectives on Politics, 2014

What Americans Want
vs. What Congress Does

On issue after issue, Congress consistently fails to pass legislation that has overwhelming public support. This is not a partisan problem — it’s a structural one. When money determines access and access determines outcomes, popularity stops mattering.

Public Support vs. Congressional Action on Key Policy Issues (% Nationwide Support)
Source: Gallup; Pew Research Center; Morning Consult polling aggregates 2023-2024. "Enacted" reflects whether federal legislation passed during 2013-2024 period. Items marked "Blocked/No Action" failed to pass despite majority support.

What Most Americans Actually Want

  • 88% support universal background checks for gun purchases
  • 83% support Medicare negotiating drug prices
  • 72% support higher taxes on the wealthy
  • 68% support raising the minimum wage to $15+
  • 64% support paid family leave

The Congressional Reality

  • Universal background checks: blocked repeatedly in Senate
  • Drug pricing: passed partially in 2022, watered down under industry pressure
  • Wealth tax: never reached a floor vote
  • $15 federal minimum wage: last raised in 2009 at $7.25
  • Paid leave: United States is the only wealthy nation with no federal policy

Trust, Incumbency,
and the Approval Paradox

Congress has a 15% approval rating. 97% of incumbents who ran in 2024 won re-election. This is not an accident — it’s the result of gerrymandering, campaign finance advantages, and name recognition systems that make almost all seats structurally non-competitive.

Congressional Approval Rating vs. Incumbent Re-Election Rate (2000-2024)
Source: Gallup approval polling; OpenSecrets incumbent re-election tracking; Ballotpedia congressional race data. Approval reflects average annual approval rating for respective election year cycles.
97%
Incumbents Re-Elected in 2024
Despite 15% congressional approval rating
$2.4M
Average House Re-Election Campaign Cost
vs. $1.3M for challenger — incumbent fundraising advantage, OpenSecrets 2024
94%
House Races Won by the Better-Funded Candidate
Historical average since 2000 — OpenSecrets
35
Truly Competitive House Seats in 2024
Out of 435 total — roughly 8% of all races

The Donor Class
Doesn’t Look Like America

Political money does not come from the population. It comes from a narrow, predominantly white, predominantly male, predominantly wealthy sliver of it. The donor class writes the agenda — and that agenda reflects who they are, not who the country is.

Who Actually Gives Political Money vs. U.S. Population Demographics
Source: Demos "Stacked Deck" report; Brennan Center for Justice; FEC 2024 donor demographic analysis. Figures reflect $200+ federal contribution donors.

In 2024, more than 90% of $200+ federal contributions came from majority-white neighborhoods. People of color account for only 10% of individual political contributions. Women of color: just 2%. The donor class writes the policy agenda — and it does not look like America.

Demos, “Stacked Deck”; Brennan Center for Justice 2024
Public Trust in Federal Government — % Who Trust Government "Always" or "Most of the Time" (1958-2025)
Source: Pew Research Center — Public Trust in Government: 1958-2025 (December 2025). Trust peaked at 77% in 1964 after the Civil Rights Act. It has never returned to that level.
Sources & Citations
Pew Research Center — Public Trust in Government: 1958-2025 (Dec. 2025) — pewresearch.org
OpenSecrets — Federal Lobbying Set New Record in 2024 (Feb. 2025) — opensecrets.org
OpenSecrets — By the Numbers: 15 Years of Citizens United (Jan. 2025) — opensecrets.org
Brennan Center for Justice — Dark Money Hit a Record High of $1.9 Billion in 2024 Federal Races — brennancenter.org
Brennan Center for Justice — Voting Laws Roundup 2024 — brennancenter.org
Martin Gilens & Benjamin Page — Testing Theories of American Politics: Elites, Interest Groups, and Average Citizens — Perspectives on Politics, 2014
Demos — Stacked Deck: How the Racial Bias in Our Political System Undermines Our Democracy — demos.org
Ballotpedia — Congressional incumbent re-election rates 2000-2024 — ballotpedia.org
Gallup — Congressional Approval historical polling — gallup.com